Question:
Should I buy Windows XP or Vista?
pinacoladaxb
2008-09-07 15:10:43 UTC
I don't know much about windows computers, so I need a bit of help picking one out. Basically what it comes down to is should I get Windows XP or Vista?

My needs:
-To play games (Unreal Tournament 3, etc.)
-To make games (using Multimedia Fusion 2)

My do-not-needs:
-A laptop

If you want to be the absolute most helpful person in the whole world to me, who I will be in debt to and remember constantly for the rest of my life, you will help me by answering these questions:

1. Should I buy XP or Vista (duh)
2. What other specifications should I watch out for when purchasing the computer?
3. (optional for bonus points) How do I get the best deal?

THANK YOU SO MUCH!
That is, if I do get any answers. :D
Sixteen answers:
bztang
2008-09-07 16:09:29 UTC
1. Should I buy XP or Vista (duh)

The main reason you should want to get XP rather than Vista is because it costs less and runs better on lower end hardware. If you buy a laptop, it will most likely come pre-loaded with Vista and due to some driver issues, XP may not be compatible with it. Vista runs fine, very little difference to XP when you have a decent dual core system, and I must stress than to get a similar experience on Vista and XP, you do not need anything more than a 500$ dual core, futureshop PC with an upgraded video card for games.



2. What other specifications should I watch out for when purchasing the computer?

For gaming and making games 3D modelling, etc, I suggest you get a laptop with at least 3gigs of RAM, which is standard on mid-range models, a dedicated video card (not shared) - from Nvidia, I'd say anything better than an 8800 would do the trick, and from ATI/AMD anything better than a 3850. (The higher the model number the bettter - usually). Anything better than Pentium dual core such as Core 2 Duo T5550, is fine, since getting a faster processor for the same laptop usually costs quite a bit. For a laptop 250gig or more hard drive is fair.

3. (optional for bonus points) How do I get the best deal?

To get a good deal you have to know what you want first, then usually major retailers such as Best Buy will have decent sales. You can also try ncix.com or newegg.com.

http://reviews.cnet.com/best-laptops/?ta...

Cnet does some pretty decent review of laptops and other electronics.

http://www.notebookreview.com/

http://www.laptopreviewsonline.com/

are also good sites.

4. Personally, I would not buy and use a laptop as my main computer. I'm using a custom built, Core 2 Quad Q6600, 4gigs ram (64bit Vista to be able to use more than 3gigs), triple 500gig WD HDD, 8800GT, Blu-ray+HD-DVD, all overclocked and aftermarket air-cooled. You can get this rig for about a grand now, with a better CPU and vid card, and even more ram, and that shall I say, is way more than enough to play UT3 and for multimedia usage. I recently also bought a new laptop for university, an Acer Aspire One netbook with XP, 8.9" WSVGA for only 420$ plus shipping, and since it's for school, I only need it to run MS word, powerpoint, read PDF's and go online with a battery that lasts up to 7hours, which this does way better than an iPhone or smartphone and it is also way more portable than a regular sized laptop. Honestly, for a grand...you cannot really get a decent laptop for gaming or design, so unless your planning to buy a desktop replacement laptop that weighs 9lbs with dismal battery life, for at least $1500, I suggest getting a desktop for power usage at home and a netbook for light work and internet on the go.



Lastly - for those who said Vista need expensive hardware... that is completely untrue - 4gigs of DDR2 800mhz RAM can be bought for as low as 40$, a 500gig HD for 80$, a geforce 8800GT for 130$, q6600 or E8400 for less than 230$ or E7200 for 140$, plus decent motherboard with wifi 130$, case +psu 100$, windows vista premium oem 130$, so for less than 900$ or 800$ before taxes, you can get a pretty beastly desktop (add a 22" monitor for 200$ or 24"for 350$), whereas something like this on a laptop would be at 1500-2000$ easily.
Duncan Henderson
2008-09-07 15:15:26 UTC
Vista uses a lot of resources compared to XP, so you need a faster computer with more memory and a bigger hard drive to get the same results.



The advantage of Vista is it's prettier and Microsoft would love for everyone to buy a copy because they want the money.



The downside to Vista is it's new.

Most of the software in the shops has been made for XP, so it might or it might not run on top of Vista.

If it does run; everything will be slower if you run Vista (because Vista takes up so many of your system resources)



I'd go for XP.

It works, they've got most of the bugs out, while Vista's still buggy





Edit:

I just reread your question.



If you're buying a new computer from a major dealer, you'll have to have Vista.



Microsoft wants everyone to buy it & they have the leverage with the OEMs and big dealers.
?
2016-05-22 02:24:22 UTC
??? If it comes w/Vista, it'll have it (or you can burn it) on CD. & doesn't Dell cut a deal for a XP/Vista upgrade combo? (So you get both.) EDIT: "I don't think it comes with a CD. The OS is pre-installed. Isn't that common?" Yeah, and it sucks. But that means (unless it was erased) Windows archive files are on your HDD and can be burned to a CD. Unless they've stopped doing that in the last couple of years. And whatever else, you should be able to get a CD from Dell for a minimal fee since you've already got a COA (Serial # Tag) on the laptop itself. "If I have a serious crash, if I have a CD I may not have to pay a tech to fix it?" Yeah, but it would still maybe mean losing anything extra (documents, spreadsheets,etc) on the HDD (Hard drive). As an aside, if you're looking at XP, make sure the model you've got has XP drivers available or else it will be a serious pain.
anonymous
2008-09-07 15:20:44 UTC
Get XP. I had Vista and it definately still has some flaws on it. Vista does show potential, but it's gonna take another service pack before it becomes good. Xp is best for gaming and making games. If you're a gamer and want a good system, be sure it has an Intel or AMD 3.0GHz processor or faster, minimal of 2GB of RAM and nice size hard drive. Atleast 160GB with how big games and other files are, that space will be necessary and if you want best graphics, I suggest GeForce FX 8200 graphics card, or higher. To get the best deal, do some research on computer hardware and what's best cause every month, something better comes out.
razmataz
2008-09-07 15:43:32 UTC
Hie



Let me make your job quite easy.



If you choose XP you would be able to use all your old programs and games.If you are looking for speed more reliablility then go for XP.I think you need it for games So go with XP.



Incase you go for VISTA you need to keep few things in mind.you need to regularly backup your information because Vista crashes anytime and its not yet that stable. Second even if ya put a 4GB Ram you will find it much slower.Vista requires High end (expensive hardware) . No doubt you will have excellent graphics etc. But wait for sometime 1 year or so before switching to Vista. Microsoft is selling XP till 2010 and supporting the same just because they know Vista has a rough edge and XP is popular with everybosy from 10-80 years....



I am a dell certified technician in 25 disciplines

regards



RAZMATAZ
Chewy
2008-09-07 16:22:47 UTC
For starters, no Windows/Microtoss OS is stable.



So comparing Vista to XP in stability is pointless.



The only crashes I've had with my Vista PC have been to do with hardware.



Vista runs fine now. Needs minimum 1Gb RAM, 2 if you can get it.



I run BF2142, BF2, Hellgate:London, Orange Box, all works fine.
mdigitale
2008-09-07 15:13:40 UTC
I personally use Vista and have had no problems. I recommend buying a lot of ram though -- then you can run Virtual PC to run XP or whatever OS you want on top of Vista. It works great and 0 compatibility problems.
<(-^_^-)>
2008-09-07 15:21:15 UTC
i bought a vista, its really easy to use and it comes with great programs that are really entertaining to use. It does have good graphics for like games and stuff, i did not buy and XP because they are a little more complicated and are becoming obsolete. And besides Windows are going to cut the XP from being made any more.
KK
2008-09-07 15:14:17 UTC
Vista unless you get some awesome deal on an older computer with XP.
Skor12
2008-09-07 15:22:33 UTC
Vista
TW
2008-09-07 15:14:47 UTC
I would say Windows XP, since some games you can't download on Vista. Amazonis probably the best place to buy it.
davj61
2008-09-07 17:54:56 UTC
I vote for Vista. It was off to a rough start in its first year, but now it is great.
ANONYMOUS
2008-09-07 17:13:42 UTC
ONLY GET VISTA if YOU HAVE 4gb ram! Becaseu only vista can take advnatage of that and your computer will be faster

But anyhting less than 4gb of ram get XP pro i have this for like 6 years now and its cool
anonymous
2008-09-07 15:14:15 UTC
I think Vista is better
anonymous
2008-09-07 19:39:48 UTC
have you tried hacintosh is leopard that runs on a pc
Lwe
2008-09-07 15:18:10 UTC
take xp


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...