Question:
whats best for me? laptop or desktop?
campkillgemma
2008-03-25 02:57:34 UTC
i was wondering what would be best for me, a laptop or a desktop, ill be using it mostly doing design work eg. photoshop, flash, dreamweaver, director. Also id like to be able to run the PC game Prey on it since i havent had a chance to play that yet.

The only down side about a desktop is im stuck on one place and i liked the freedom of moving about with a laptop. A good thing bout a desktop is for the same price of a laptop i can get a better spec desktop.

im in two minds about this, someone help me please
Fourteen answers:
anonymous
2008-03-25 03:11:59 UTC
The way you described what you want to do with it and the fact you like to be mobile. I would say get a laptop. I'm not sure if it will run the game Prey though. You would have to check out the specs. Good luck on your decision.
asig33882003
2008-03-25 15:36:52 UTC
I have a couple thoughts here, so bear w/ me.



First of all, most people who buy laptops don't really move them enough to warrant spending the extra money (smaller components cost more to give you equivalent specs to a desktop, like you said). Unless you're going to move it around a lot, need to use it on the go, are going to take advantage of free public wi-fi, etc. then the laptop is not going to benefit you much. No offense, but taking your laptop to bed w/ you isn't so much a need for mobility, it's just kind of laziness and not wanting to walk from the desk to bed. Also, keep in mind, that laptops are more prone to problems. If you use it on battery power a lot, then you'll have to replace the battery within about a year, which costs around $100. Also, if you leave the laptop plugged in all the time, that also ruins the battery. Another problem with laptops is that in time, the fans seem to go out fairly often, and then you either need to fix that (expensive repair) or risk overheating the system, which could cause a lot of damage.



My second thought is that I think you are better off having a separate system for gaming. I think you're much better served with a platform gamestation, like an X-Box or Playstation. More stable, less corruption. However, if you're in love w/ computer gaming, I would recommend a separate computer that you can devote specifically to gaming.



Another idea is that I think a really good way to do it is to have both a desktop and a laptop. You can use the desktop for your more high powered operations (games, photos, music downloads, videos) and have that kind of be your master system. Then you can utilize a laptop for mobile internet and word processing. This way you can buy a basic, low-featured laptop (or just reformat and use your old one) and have mobility as an option, but then you've got your good system in place for those activities you do at the computer from home.



You get these people that decide they need to be mobile so they buy a laptop, but they're really just want that option "just in case." People commonly buy a laptop and then want an external wireless keyboard and mouse, external speakers, a docking station, an external monitor, a cooling pad for it to sit on, and a USB hub, so that they can support all these external devices. If you go through the hassle of hooking all this up, you'll have just as much of a cable mess as a desktop anyway. And you won't want to move the laptop b/c then you'll have to hook all that other stuff up again.



Just some things to consider.
anonymous
2008-03-25 03:10:49 UTC
It depends on what is more important to you, price or mobility.



A desktop costing the same as a laptop will have a much better spec than the laptop. It is also more future proof as it is easier to upgrade a desktop with new hardware than it is with a laptop



Personally I would always have the desktop but if mobility is essential you've really got to have a laptop.

I can't think of any currently available laptop that will not run the programs you've mentioned.
Everona97
2008-03-25 03:05:48 UTC
I had desktop for ages and it worked for me very well. Around Valentine's I had to buy a laptop as I was on the move and needed to do work at more than 1 place and preferably on the 1 machine (all that USB sticks, Cd's are nightmare to move from comp to comp and some times I realised that I forgot to copy folder... OK, you got a picture). I am really for laptop now: save space, save time and you are not stuck. Good Luck!
anonymous
2008-03-25 07:06:59 UTC
Desktop all the way! You will need a above average GPU and lappies max of 8600/2600 just won't cut it!



Q6600 = $255

Gigabyte P35DS3L = $90

4GB (2 x 2) Geil Value Series ddr2 800 RAMs = $63

Seagate 500gb/32mb cache HDD = $110

HD 3870 = $175

Liteon DVD Burner = $24

Antec Sonata 3 casing + Earthwatts 500W = $80 (buy.com)

64 bit Home Premium = $100

Total = $897, prices off Newegg and buy.com
anonymous
2008-03-25 03:17:30 UTC
Laptop is definitely more portable, I have laptop but would prefer to go back to a desktop, I find working at the laptop hard work, keyboard mouse etc, so depends what work you will be doing, but you get far superior spec machine for your money with a desktop, hope this helps.
anonymous
2008-03-25 03:15:27 UTC
a laptop is good for porrtability, but from my use of it i have found it will be no good for games like that, unless you spend a fair bit of cash. laptops cost about the same for the same specs as a desktop computer.



laptop is ok if you get a laptop with a good spec (esp. good process power!)

you are probably better off getting a desktop pc, better for running your programs.
Mad Scientist has Retired. Bye!!
2008-03-25 06:26:07 UTC
I recommend a desktop. It will be cheaper though it has same spec with laptop. If you use desktop, you will get professional graphic card like ATi FireGL or Nvidia Quadro. If you use laptop, you won't get professional graphic card.
Danny
2008-03-25 03:07:25 UTC
i think at some point you will need a laptop eventually. why not go invest your money into the future and pick the laptop.

the price burns at first but the convenience is immeasurable.
anonymous
2008-03-25 07:11:20 UTC
I have both which makes it handy if i am going on long journeys. Maybe you should get both if you can afford it you wouldn't regret doing this.
Sibego
2008-03-25 03:11:44 UTC
I can see that you want the laptop, go for it !
anonymous
2008-03-25 03:03:00 UTC
Hm...

Do you like to go everywhere?

I think laptop is good.

But if you like to stay at home, PC is good.

But, if laptop, be careful abut gaming.

laptop is too small and smooth.

Better you choose laptop.

it can play many games.





[Programmer]
Aly W
2008-03-25 03:05:16 UTC
laptop because you can go into starbucks and be all cool and sophisticated... lol lame but its my dream!
suzan
2008-03-25 03:02:27 UTC
i think u cn use laptop


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...