Question:
Which is safer, Mac or PC?
louie
2009-06-17 14:51:39 UTC
I am saving up for a new laptop, my last laptop was an HP with Windows Vista. I got it in June 07, and pretty much it stopped working after a crash in Feb 09, so I have been with out a laptop for a while now. I have used my brothers Mac Book, but I have not used it a whole lot, but I have been using it mainly for the internet. I have not really had a whole lot of problems with it.
I have been researching but I still need more answers.

Do Macs crash and freeze as easily as Windows? Which Laptop lasts more? I want a laptop that will last me for a long time, unlike my last laptop.

I am pretty much choosing between a Sony Vaio FW and a Mac book.
If anyone is going to recommend the Sony Vaio one, are there anyway to keep Windows from crashing and freezing? Also would I be able to get rid of viruses? How can I avoid viruses altogether?
Thanks in advance!
Six answers:
2009-06-17 15:01:57 UTC
I hope I'm not going to get in the middle of a firefight between Mac and Windows fanatics.



Mac is a more stable platform, but you can do more with Windows. It is also easier to get software for Windows.



But this is a decision you must make for yourself.
Serenity
2009-06-17 22:16:17 UTC
There are two main differences between a Macintosh and a Windows based PC. The first in hardware and software related and the other is about market share and malware. I will discuss the hardware/software issue first as it is really the major difference. First, the real difference is that the Windows OS uses what is called the Registry. This is the heart of the OS and it stores every single feature and command for both the OS and the applications installed on top of the OS, as well as every driver for the hardware to "talk" with the software.



The registry is critical to proper system, program, and hardware functionality. If anything goes wrong with the registry it can cause anything from a fatal crash to all sorts of annoying to serious issues with the OS and programs, hardware. For example, if a single registry entry becomes corrupt, depending on what the entry is related to, lets say the cammand to start iTunes, iTunes will not be able to start. It could be something more serious such as icons missing, features missing or not responding correctly, your keyboard could malfunction, and the list goes on forever. Every program and feature is inside the registry, so you can see how sensitive it is to errors. When you install a program it is entered into the registry, that is where the commands for every single feature is stored. When you want to remove a program often registry keys are left behind. The more programs you install and remove the more registry "bloat" you get in the system. While there ARE so called "registry cleaners" these types of tools are actually bad for the system. You can never tell when they remove a valid and vital key, and when this occurs the issues may not show up right away but eventually they do and all sorts of odd issues will begin to occur, without rhyme or reason.



Another issue with Windows based PCs is that the systems which are built for you and which come with the OS pre-installed are stuffed with useless trial or "free" programs, with the worst of the bunch being either Norton or McAfee security suite. Security suites must embed deeply into the OS, and if you want to use a different vendor you MUST fully and completely remove the one which is installed, which is nearly impossible and when it seems removed it really is not. Then you install another vendors product and all sorts of issues occur. They can begin right away or wait for a trigger event and can actually cause a fatal crash.



The Apple Macintosh does not utilize a registry so it is far more stable than a Windows based PC. As for the second issue, security, the Mac is just as prone to viruses or other malware as Windows. It is just as prone to being remotely taken over. The only reason the Mac appears more secure is because it has such a small market share. Malware writers tend to write for the largest market share. This is because the code they write will work on a larger number of machines. But, don't let anyone tell you that a Mac is more secure because of the way it is built, that isn't true.



Don't get me wrong here, Windows has a real good place in the market. Windows opened up more people to access the Internet and use systems than any other OS. It is made cheaply and that was passed on to consumers. This is why it has been so popular, and spread across the world so quickly. Microsoft went for the fast nickles instead of slow dimes. Bill Gates made billions while placing more computers in businesses, hospitals, government, and homes than any other company.



If you can afford a Mac, and have the hardware to support it then go with the Mac. The Mac is a far more solid machine and will last a long time. This is not to say that with the appropriate care a Windows based system will not also last a very long time. By only installing the software you are positive you will use, and keeping away from the stuff you are interested in, but never use once installed, by not removing software once it IS installed, staying away from known malware websites, and keeping the system up to date with updates and driver updates and using a solid security system Windows can and will last as long as a Mac. The problem is that most people do not know how to take care of their system. So, if you like the Mac and can afford it by all means buy one, but be sure to install a security system, at the very least an anti-virus.
2009-06-17 22:03:30 UTC
Since Mac's use the exact same parts as a PC, the reliability and safety will be the same. The only difference is the operating system, and if you like the Mac OS then you can always get it for the sony.

All computers can crash, and all computers can get viruses, Mac's just don't have antivirus software to view the viruses that they have.

So it really comes down to how much do you want to spend.

The Mac's cost more but have the same parts as the sony, nobody knows why they cost more.

You don't get what you pay for when buying a Mac.
JeR
2009-06-17 22:29:56 UTC
1, Cost -- PC is cheap

2. Loss time to repair - PC (Dell is worst / MAC is number 2) then HP / Sony are the lowest.

3. Off shelf parts - PC - cost lower

4. Virus - both are equal - Best anti-virus is the matter between your ears.

5. Best keyboard and screen - MAC

6. Solid case - MAC - the worst to work on - most cases return to MAC service centers.

7. Most programs and games - PC

8. Graphics and photo edit - MAC

9. Games and word/spreadsheets - PC

10. Networking and Internet - Equal.



It is your call, since you know PC OS. If you purchase new system, ask if you can get W7 or new MAC OS, both will be out this fall. If they said no, then leave and found a store will. Savings amount ???
dallenmarket
2009-06-17 22:51:49 UTC
The Mac is almost totally immune to virii and trojan horses primarily due to the fact that virus writers want a big audience and easy to break through security. (as in Windows) Also many virus writers actually write their code on Macs. That way they can't kill their own computer! The Mac has throughout its history had a couple of dozen virii produced and they were taken care of through simple means. (without the need for virus removal software except in a couple of cases like the DNS Changer that has a freeware program available that detects and removes it with no problems.) Windows has thousands. There is no way to be totally protected as it takes a while before the antivirus software can be updated for new virii. Most Macs never use any antivirus software and have never needed it. (except for some fools who downloaded one from some torrent sites in bogus and illegal versions of iLife. I compare that to being robbed while in the ghetto trying to buy drugs!)



The OS doesn't lock up or freeze like ANY version of Windows. If you do get a freeze because of a software problem (very rare, but some 3rd party apps don't play well with others.) it's a simple matter to "force quit" that application and nothing is corrupted or needs repair and the Mac doesn't need to start up all over.



Windows crashes and freezes. It is a fact of life for ALL Windows users. Most people I know are thrilled because they've gone a few days and ecstatic if they go a couple of weeks without a freeze. They don't believe me when I tell them MY computer doesn't freeze or crash.



I constantly hear PC people ranting about the "high price" of Macs. If you could find a PC with the quality of parts that are standard on a Mac it would probably cost MORE. Macs are the best quality you can buy. I've had my PowerBook G4 in my 18 wheeler being bounced and banged for a few years now and it has never given me a bit of trouble. I also still have an old PowerBook 1400 upgraded to G3/233 that I carried to Iraq for a year. It still works great, although it can only run up to OS 9 and most of my newer applications and games need OS 10. It also is not wireless internet capable, which I need on the road. My wireless software requires OS 10, thus the PowerBook G4. The main reason I haven't replaced my G4 with a newer, faster MacBook is that it still does everything I need, so why spend the money!



The only downside to any of the newer laptops is they are not upgradeable as far as processor speed. Any Mac will become too slow for new programs before it wears out. (As in the previously mentioned PB 1400.) I even have a Mac SE30 that is around 20 years old. Still works great. (If you don't mind a 9" screen and working in OS 7)



BTW: If you have some Windows programs that you'd like to use, the Mac will allow it. You can install Windows XP or Vista and run it on the Mac under Bootstrap. (a free included part of the Mac OS) You can NOT put the Mac OS on a Windows PC and run Mac programs.



When Windows freezes under Bootstrap, it's a simple matter to restart Bootstrap, like any program. The Mac has not been hurt and Windows virii can't go through Windows and attack a Mac either. (and you don't need to "reinstall" Windows to fix it!)



I use VPC and Windows XP on occasion. (The older Macs can't run Bootstrap, so we use a program called Virtual PC, which is slower than Bootstrap, but lets us use Windows apps if we want.)



I don't run any antivirus software and have never been able to get one, no matter what downloads or where I visit on the internet while in Windows mode. The Mac interface doesn't appear to allow the virii to attack Windows, even though the same version of Windows in a PC (from the same installation disk, without antivirus software, in a Compaq) got more than 70 pieces of spyware, 6 trojan horses and 45 virii while surfing the internet for less than 2 hours. (It was a test I did with a PC that was given to me.)
Nemo the geek
2009-06-17 22:02:00 UTC
My pc never crashes. Get CA anti-virus, its free with TimeWarner cable. Crashes happen if you download from the wrong sites. Be careful what you download, usually if it takes too long to download or it stalls, cancel it, thats a bad sign. If worse comes to worse all you have to do is re-install windows, try that with your laptop. All virus's go away when you do a new install of Windows. Save your money, nobody knows how to fix a Mac.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...